Be honest: does your current plan survive a bad month?
Most founders plan for one scenario, the optimistic one. When reality shows up, and it always does, they have no room to move.
Model three versions of the year
Every significant financial decision should be modeled three ways:
| Scenario | Rough odds | Assumes |
|---|---|---|
| Optimistic | 25% | Everything goes to plan |
| Realistic | 50% | Some things go wrong, some go right |
| Conservative | 25% | Most things go wrong |
The rule: make decisions that work in the realistic case and survive the conservative one.
The odds aren’t a prediction. They’re a discipline. They stop you from treating the best case as the expected case, and they put the most weight on the version of the year where some things break and some things work out.
What “work” and “survive” mean
The rule has two halves, and they test different things.
- Works in the realistic case: the decision still makes sense if growth comes in below plan and a few things slip. It still moves the business forward.
- Survives the conservative case: if most things go wrong, the decision doesn’t sink the company. You can still make payroll, and you still have time to change course.
A decision that only works in the optimistic case is a bet on everything going right. Sometimes that bet is worth making. It should be made on purpose, not by default because nobody built the other two cases.
Apply it to a real decision
Say you have $500K in the bank and two options. Option A is hiring three engineers, about $450K a year in fixed salary. Option B is putting $450K into customer acquisition. Both, on paper, double revenue in 12 months.
In the optimistic case they look equal. In the conservative case they don’t. Marketing spend is variable: you can see results in real time and adjust it week to week. Salaries are a fixed cost that’s hard to reverse. When most things go wrong, Option B lets you pull back. Option A keeps billing you.
That’s what three scenarios do to a decision. They make you ask which path leaves you more choices later, not just which one has the best return. More in Optionality Beats Optimization.
The same test applies to debt. Before you take venture debt, ask whether you can service it in the bad case, not just the plan.
The cash version
For your overall cash position, the three cases become base, downside, and crisis, each with specific assumptions about revenue, churn, hiring, and fundraising timing. That model, and where to draw the line on runway, is in You Probably Don’t Have 18 Months of Runway.
Two audiences, two languages
Your board wants hockey sticks. Your bank account wants survival.
Investors reward big growth bets, but payroll, vendors, and runway don’t care about the story. Many startups fail not because the base case was wrong, but because they ignored the downside when they planned.
The best founders speak both languages: an ambitious growth case for the board, and disciplined cash planning for running the company. The two aren’t in conflict. The second one is what keeps you around long enough to hit the first.
Run it on your next big decision
- Write the decision in one sentence. A hire, a contract, a new market, a loan.
- Describe the three cases in plain words for the next 12 months. What has to go right for the optimistic case? What goes wrong in the conservative one?
- For each case, write down two things: what happens to cash, and whether you can reverse the decision.
- Apply the rule. If it works in the realistic case and survives the conservative one, go. If it only works in the optimistic case, shrink it, stage it, or make it easier to undo.
None of this needs a complex model. A sheet with three columns and honest assumptions is enough to change the decision.
Free assessment
Do you need a CFO yet?
Related articles
More on Fractional CFOYou Probably Don't Have 18 Months of Runway
Most runway numbers assume everything goes to plan. A simple three-scenario cash model shows how much time you really have, and when to act.
September 14, 2021 Fractional CFOOptionality Beats Optimization
Two spending options can show the same return and carry very different risk. Why fixed costs collapse your choices and how to decide where to commit.
December 17, 2024 Fractional CFOEvery Financial Model Is Wrong. Investors Know That.
Investors aren't looking for accurate projections. They're looking for logic. What to show about assumptions, sensitivity, and how you'll adapt.
February 14, 2023What's next for your company?
Reach out and I'll reply personally within two business days.
