My job isn’t to be liked. It’s to tell the truth.
Sometimes that means raising the same issue more than once, knowing the founder doesn’t want to hear it:
- The burn isn’t sustainable.
- The hire is premature.
- The pricing doesn’t work.
- The program needs to go.
- This employee isn’t the right fit.
I keep pushing, not because I enjoy the tension, but because it’s my job to tell them the facts as I know them. The job isn’t to make founders comfortable. It’s to keep them solvent. Sometimes that means being the person who says the thing no one else will say.
Then it’s their call
I advocate hard, bring the data, make the case, and don’t soften the message. Then it’s the founder’s company. Once they decide, I execute fully. No resentment, no “I told you so.”
That balance is the whole job. A CFO who won’t push back isn’t useful. A CFO who keeps fighting after the decision is made is worse, because now the founder has to manage their finance lead on top of everything else.
How I push matters too. You can disagree, push hard, and demand rigor without condescension or escalation. Firm and regulated at the same time is what makes a hard message possible to hear.
Not the “no” person
Founders often see CFOs as gatekeepers:
- “Too expensive.”
- “Not in the budget.”
- “Let’s revisit this next quarter.”
Good CFOs sit next to you, not across from you. Yes, we track burn and care about budgets. But we’re not there to kill ideas. We’re there to help them survive the trip. We don’t clip wings. We make sure you don’t stall mid-flight.
The questions a good CFO asks sound different from “no”:
- Is this spend aligned with the vision, or a detour?
- Is this growth real, or just noise?
- Can we sustain this pace, or are we burning out?
So when you’re weighing a move, ask your CFO what’s possible, not just what’s affordable. And expect more than a verdict. People resist predictions, but they act on options. More on that in Useful Beats Right.
Not an expensive babysitter
A lot of financial management is expensive babysitting:
- Tracking every expense in real time.
- Reports that sit unread in inboxes.
- Problems flagged after they’ve already happened.
- Processes that slow decisions down.
That’s theater. Good financial management looks different: systems that prevent problems before they start, dashboards that drive decisions, trends spotted early enough to change course. It gives founders the confidence to move faster, not slower.
Telling the truth is part of that. A report that confirms what everyone hoped is easy to write. The useful one says what’s actually happening, early enough to act on it.
The best pairs disagree
I used to think being a “pessimistic” CFO was a curse. I had a knack for spotting potential pitfalls and risks.
Then I worked with a founder whose vision was as sharp as it was magnetic. I was skeptical at first, worried his big ambitions might cause financial problems. Our differences turned out to be the strength: he saw five steps ahead, and my job was making sure we took the next one with both feet on the ground. He wanted more sales reps to close more deals. The numbers showed the current team still had room to grow, and hiring more would burn cash without a matching return. We argued, adjusted, and landed somewhere better than either starting point.
The best founder relationships I have aren’t the ones where we always agree. They’re the ones where I can push back hard, and then fully back the decision. For why that tension works, see Visionary Founder, Realist CFO: Why the Pairing Works.
Check whether you’re hearing the truth
Ask yourself:
- When did someone last tell you something about the business you didn’t want to hear?
- Did they bring data and options, or just an opinion?
- Once you decided, did they get behind it?
- Is there an issue someone has raised more than once that you keep putting off?
If you can’t remember the last hard conversation, that doesn’t mean there’s nothing to say. It may mean nobody feels able to say it.
The founders who thrive don’t surround themselves with yes-people. They hire people willing to tell them the truth, and then trust them enough to listen.
Free assessment
Do you need a CFO yet?
Related articles
More on Fractional CFOVisionary Founder, Realist CFO: Why the Pairing Works
Founders see what could be. CFOs see what could go wrong. How the best founder/CFO partnerships turn that tension into a plan that is both bold and doable.
January 14, 2021 Fractional CFOUseful Beats Right
People resist predictions and act on options. Why financial advice needs a recommendation, and the better questions founders should ask their CFO.
April 9, 2024 Fractional CFO"That's Not My Department" Is a Red Flag in a CFO
A good CFO spots the problem. A great one owns the fix, even when it lives in marketing, product, or sales. Why the best CFOs treat the whole business as their job.
March 16, 2021What's next for your company?
Reach out and I'll reply personally within two business days.
